Authoritarian drift

A national political context

The US example clearly shows that—as Umberto Eco pointed out in his essay "Ur-Fascism"—the rise of fascism relies on:

  1. an authoritarian drift,
  2. seeking to control the speech of political opposition,
  3. often targeting minorities already victims of oppression,
  4. through a distortion of language and concepts.

As a result, the left, workers already exploited, and minorities of origin or gender are particularly targeted by social and political pressure.

In France, however, the bulk of attacks remains the work of an "ordinary" far right, de-demonized and highlighted by a desperate extreme center. They operate through "small" friction: contempt, covert discrimination, ridicule, minimization, censorship and silencing of expressions…

These threats are very real in 2026, in France, with the rise of the far right, supported by the irresponsible extreme center. To counter them, every action, no matter how small, counts.

A support…

Right now, you can see the authoritarian drift every day, with the shameful way the government treats our legitimate social struggles. The world, Europe and France are not spared by this authoritarian drift, to the point that even the director general of the Institut Pasteur has expressed concern about it.

The general management has moreover expanded with a Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DEI) department, which notably funds "clubs" seeking to support minorities, such as the Queer Club, with which the management officially took part in the Pride March.

The Institute has also seen the creation of Employees Resource Groups (ERG), groups of employees supposedly meant to report to certain departments on possible actions concerning DEI and the environment. Far from being entirely disinterested, the creation of these ERGs was also a necessary condition for obtaining certain European fundings…

It can be noted that in France, labor law grants the Social and Economic Committee (CSE) a monopoly on the organization of social actions. This monopoly exists to prevent the employer from seizing control of all aspects of workers' lives, and from using this power to impose its agenda, as has been seen throughout history. The ERGs organized and funded by management are therefore a manifest violation of labor law, against which the Pasteur CSE does not fight, as long as management does not abuse (and it is obviously starting to abuse, as we shall see).

Of course, the speeches given by management at its social events (New Year's greetings, Town Halls, etc.) are all steeped in grand words about support for minorities, democracy and precarious workers.

We nevertheless welcome these initiatives, because in the face of the rise of fascism, any help is welcome.

… with variable geometry

However, between the fine, proactive speeches of the new management's grace period and reality, there is now an unfathomable gulf.

This authoritarian drift has the same causes as the authoritarian drift within the government (lack of democracy, the myth of excellence, widespread precariousness, the insularity of the ruling class, etc.)

For example, during its two participations in the Pride March, management (despite union warnings reminding it of the illegality of the measure) required employees in the procession to sign a form committing them to "not broadcast or carry any messages […] of a political nature," on pain of sanctions. Slogans had to be "pre-approved by the communications department" (we like that one, you'll see) 1.

And indeed, some slogans were censored, without explanation (mainly those mentioning trans identity… yes, yes, like in the USA). For the Pride March, which is a "political and protest demonstration, against the reactionary international and its attempts at recuperation"—in the organizers' own words—censorship imposed through threats seems quite inappropriate. Especially when management takes advantage of pinkwashing to buy itself a rosy progressive image.

On the Green Team ERG front, the "Social and Environmental Responsibility" (CSR) department has evolved into a body for filtering and controlling the activity of the workers involved. The watchword is above all not to propose anything "political" (a term which, in our technocrats' mouths, means "that we disagree with").

For example, during the meeting between the Green Team and the director general, the question raised by workers about the termination of the partnership between the Institute and the ecocidal bank BNP was conveniently set aside by the CSR department. The deputy director general is equally implicated, since he also tried to silence our union representative on this subject, on the grounds that he… asked too many questions (well, it's true that we ask too many questions, especially the ones we shouldn't).

The subject of salaries, moreover, seems to divide management, since before last year's negotiations, the director had assured (sworn and promised) the unions that she would give them the allocated budget envelope, so that they could negotiate its distribution. Alas, this information was never provided, and the HR director absolutely refused all union demands, even those uniting all the unions and costing the Institute nothing more.

This year, salary negotiations look set to be treated with even more contempt by management, which, after brazenly lying about the Institute's financial situation, is preparing to shamelessly sink everyone's purchasing power, and especially that of the "less excellent."

Censorships that keeps repeating

Far from being an isolated event, the censorship of political speech (concerning the organization of work or our Institute's positioning) has multiplied recently.

At the last New Year's greetings, for example, the intervention of elected staff representatives was censored on the videoconference 3, at the express request of the communications director. DirComm also refused to take questions from elected representatives at the last Town Hall, in favor of questions "sent in advance" (whose origin you can easily imagine—we see you, Henri) and a call to go "have a drink across the street" (sic!), which was at the very least ill-advised and contemptuous 4.

Before the summer, the HR director had sent a general email about freedom of expression, in which he mixed legitimate reminders of the law with questionable interpretations of rules, all in a threatening tone. This message came conveniently after elected representatives called out illegal actions by the HR department, which have fortunately since been rectified.

Last year, management pressured the STAPA association twice, in order to force it to put an end to discussions concerning the Palestinian genocide and salary negotiations. On the main mailing list, the director of education notably challenged and threatened a doctoral student at the end of their contract (who was sharing the latest information on career development for young precarious workers) by accusing them of sharing "fake news" 5. The email was also forwarded as is by the DEI director to the doctoral student representatives. An elected representative wanted to send a message demonstrating that it was the director of education who was out of touch with reality on the ground, but there too, management's pressure on STAPA prevented the message from being delivered to the workers targeted by the threats… Recently, the control of the communication within the STAPA has been eased, since the mailing-list has beem suppressed, in favor of Microsoft Teams, where it is easier to delete messages discretly.

Even more recently, at the great CSR mass, open questions to the (meager) audience were simply canceled 6. The reason invoked to justify the removal of this meager democratic opening, yet rooted in Pasteurian culture? "We don't have time, but you can post them online and we'll answer at our leisure." We have time for a whole morning of self-congratulation, but not for a small democratic exercise, even a very limited one… The promise of a deferred response—already invoked at the last Town Hall—is obviously never followed up on 9.

Very recently, it was the communications department (again—they must really love us) that was behind a general email attempting to make workers believe they were forbidden from publicly expressing political opinions (again!) 7. This email says nothing outright false, but its phrasing is designed so that a quick reading suggests something other than what is nevertheless simple to state: in France, personal freedom of expression is guaranteed for everyone, including if you are an employee.

A disengagement from the fight against the far right

Another example, and not the least: the handling of the debate on management's positioning in the face of the rise of authoritarianism and fascism.

Two years ago, management took a stance against the far right, then in support of the Ukrainian population threatened by war. But since then, the Israeli-Palestinian war has evolved into ethnic cleansing, then into genocide recognized by the UN. Management, for its part, actively ignored the many calls from several collectives to take a position in favor of welcoming Palestinian students and scientists, or to put pressure on the Israeli government through boycotts. These calls had no other effect than the taking down of the Ukrainian flag from the front of our institute… not very classy for our image…

Yet elected representatives were encouraged by the director general herself to "talk about Palestine", because she "could not". One can only assume that this order comes directly from the board of directors, whose president justified his inaction (at a symposium on Pasteurians who resisted the Nazi regime 8, if we'd wanted to make the joke, we couldn't have made it more ridiculous) by the fact that "the Institut Pasteur cannot recognize countries". A sibylline phrase that could be read as waiting for the French state to recognize Palestine. Yet France eventually recognized the Palestinian state… without this having any effect on the position of the Institute's president.

Worse still, a peaceful demonstration organized internally on campus by a cross-partisan collective prompted the HR director of the time to send (again!) a general email calling for censorship, accompanied by threats of sanctions 2. No mention, however, of the attempts at physical intimidation (fortunately contained by security) suffered by the demonstrators.

One might have thought that the removal of the legal director, the deputy director general and his HR director (all three for having participated in and covered up an institutionalized harassment system) would calm things down, but… As an explanation for our question about this drift, the new deputy director general had offered nothing more than the claim that the problem was leafletting outside the union framework. A rather flimsy reason to allow general threats of sanctions, in our humble opinion (but perhaps because we didn't go to Sciences-Po?)

Subsequently, the Solidaires union was created (in part) to respond to this problem, a cause that no other union wished to defend. However, on several occasions, management disrupted and threatened our questions and leaflet distributions on the subject, thereby showing that this is not a simple matter of interpretation of the labor code, but indeed an assumed political decision.

An unhealthy atmosphere at the Institut Pasteur

Even more telling: very recently, the new HR director went so far as to threaten elected representatives in an email—with the labor inspector copied in. The inspector took the news very badly (capital letters and all—something no elected representative can remember ever seeing) and, unprecedentedly for the Institute, officially summoned the HR director.

The Institut Pasteur is indeed under scrutiny from the Labor Inspectorate over systemic psychosocial risks (the legal jargon for harassment, toxic management, suicide risks, etc.) and over obstructions to social dialogue.

One might have thought that an HR director hired to replace her toxic and incompetent predecessor would have held social dialogue closer to heart… But no: instead of tackling substance (the single reporting channel, for instance, awaited for years), management goes after those who raise the alarm.

More broadly, social dialogue is systematically obstructed. Remember: two years ago, workers came to voice their demands directly during a CSE meeting, since the mandatory annual negotiations were yielding nothing and board meetings were held in secret (the aristocracy has always been terrified of the people). In response, management repeatedly called in… security, to prevent demonstrations. As if they feared for their lives in the face of the workers—who were perfectly calm.

As so often, our leaders claim to love democracy. But for them, democracy is exercised elsewhere (in government? with batons?), an exercise imposed on others (on elected staff representatives, in particular)—but not on themselves.

A genuine democracy is built on checks and balances, transparent information, leaders bound by their commitments, and inalienable freedom of expression.

Where is the democracy at the Institut Pasteur?

Staff representatives now have very little power, information is manipulated or arbitrarily withheld, commitments are rotted by double standards, and now freedom of expression is under threat. Does this ring a bell? Of course it does: it's the slippery slope imposed by Macronism, applied on a smaller scale.

An illegal censorship!

Unions have each time alerted management to these censorships, sometimes contradicting management's own commitments, sometimes frankly illegal. They have never received the slightest response, despite the grand speeches about restoring social dialogue. Could the Institut Pasteur be under strong pressure to muzzle political expression, which would explain these excesses?

Freedom of expression is nonetheless a fundamental right, protected in France by nothing less than the constitution. Can your employer deny freedom of expression so frontally? Absolutely not.

The only limits to this fundamental right are:

  1. exceptions provided by law (incitement to hatred, defamation…),
  2. restrictions on the dissemination of sensitive data belonging to the employer,
  3. the employee's duty of loyalty (basically, you can't speak ill of the Institute as employees, but note that this must also be reciprocal! Note that as a union, you can ;-),
  4. limitations negotiated by the employer, in a specific context, proportionate to a specific interest of the employer (e.g., in dealings with clients). At present, there are no such limits within our Institute.

If your employer were ever to overstep these limits and sanction you, the person giving the order ** (who said the DirComm? You're cheeky) would expose themselves to criminal penalties of up to 3 years' imprisonment.**

Will we have to resort to a legal battle to protect our freedom of expression in the temple of science, while the far right threatens? One hopes not.

Notes


  1. 2024-2025 Two years in a row! Even though elected officials had warned that the measure was illegal from the very first year, it took legal threats to put a stop to it. The 2025 form is still visible on the intranet. ↩

  2. 2025-11-20 E-mail from Communication IP titled "Today's campus demonstration", whose rhetoric bears a striking resemblance to that of the current government when it suppresses political expression. ↩

  3. 2025-01-14 New Year's Greetings from Management ↩

  4. 2025-12-15 Town Hall ↩

  5. 2025-11-06 E-mail(s) on the now-defunct STAPA mailing list. ↩

  6. 2026-09-22 "A More Sustainable Institute" ↩

  7. 2026-09-16 E-mail, shown in the BIP of the 18th of September and on a page on the intranet. ↩

  8. 2025-12-10 “Citizen Researchers” Symposium ↩

  9. EDIT: we're still waiting for the answers for the Town Hall, but the “answers” for the CSR event were published in a BIP... TWO MONTHS later (get ready for some political doublespeak). ↩